As kids, we all learn that money doesn’t grow on trees. As a society on the other hand, we have become conditioned to believe that it’s not only possible but that it’s a normal, necessary and productive function of our economy. Before bitcoin, this privilege was reserved to global central banks (see here for example). Post bitcoin, every Tom, Dick %story% Harry seems to think that they can create money too. At a root level, this is the audacity of everyone that attempts to create a copy of bitcoin. Whether by hard-forking out of consensus (bitcoin cash), cloning bitcoin (litecoin) or creating a new protocol with “better” features (ethereum), each is an attempt to create a new form of money. If bitcoin could do it, why can’t we?
We sit here, in 2019, witnessing the monetization event of an economic good (bitcoin) on the free market for the first time in thousands of years (h/t gold). Rather than stopping to contemplate the weight of that reality or to understand how or why that is possible, many people skip right past it to focus on some derivative or some way to improve upon a problem they didn’t see in the first place. Everyone wants to get rich quick, and so long as there is money, there will also be alchemists. Those that attempt to copy bitcoin are our modern day alchemists.
“Everyone wants to get rich quick, and so long as there is money, there will also be alchemists.”
They tell us that bitcoin is too slow so they create a copy that is “faster”. Or they tell us that bitcoin does not have the capacity to handle the number of transactions required by the global economy so they create a copy that has “greater” scale. Then they tell us that bitcoin is too volatile to be a currency so they create a “more stable” version. It goes on and on. Next its that bitcoin is too rigid and that it needs to be more programmable so they create a copy that is “more flexible”. They often even tell us that their creation is not money but instead, it’s a vehicle for “payments” or a “utility” or maybe a “global computer fueled by gas”. They also try to convince us of a world that has hundreds, if not thousands, of currencies. But make no mistake, in each case, it is their own attempt to create money.
Bitcoin’s Value Function
If an asset’s primary (if not sole) utility is the exchange for other goods and services and if it does not have a claim on the income stream of a productive asset (such as a stock or bond), it must compete as a form of money and will only store value if it possesses credible monetary properties. With each “feature” change, those that attempt to copy bitcoin signal a failure to understand the properties that make bitcoin valuable or viable as money. When bitcoin’s software code was released, it wasn’t money. To this day, bitcoin’s software code is not money. You can copy the code tomorrow or create your own variant with a new feature and no one that has adopted bitcoin as money will treat it as such. Bitcoin has become money over time only as the bitcoin network developed emergent properties that did not exist at inception and which are next to impossible to replicate now that bitcoin exists.
“Those that attempt to copy bitcoin signal a failure to understand the properties that make bitcoin valuable or viable as money.”
These properties emerged organically and spontaneously as individual economic actors all over the world evaluated bitcoin and determined to store a portion of their wealth in it. As bitcoin’s value increased, it became decentralized and as it became decentralized, it also became increasingly difficult to alter the network’s consensus rules or to invalidate, or prevent, otherwise valid transactions (often referred to as censorship-resistance). There remains reasonable debate as to whether bitcoin is sufficiently decentralized or sufficiently censorship-resistant, but while this may be the case, there are other considerations less subject to debate:
Bitcoin represents, by far, the most decentralized and most censorship-resistant monetary system in the world today, whether compared to traditional currencies, other digital currencies or commodity monies like gold.
Bitcoin derives its value because it is decentralized and because it is censorship-resistant; it is these properties which secure and reinforce the credibility of bitcoin’s fixed 21 million supply (i.e. why it is an effective store of value).
Bitcoin becomes increasingly decentralized and increasingly censorship-resistant as its value increases and as it scales at all levels of the network.
Repeat.
Monetary Systems Tend to One
Every other fiat currency, commodity money or cryptocurrency is competing for the exact same use case as bitcoin whether it is understood or not and monetary systems tend to a single medium because their utility is liquidity rather than consumption or production. When evaluating monetary networks, it would be irrational to store value in a smaller, less liquid and less secure network if a larger, more liquid and more secure network existed as an attainable option.
Apply a common sense test. If you worked for two weeks and your employer offered to pay you in a form of currency accepted by 1 billion people all over the world or a currency accepted by 1 million people, which would you take? Would you request 99.9% of one and 0.1% of the other, or would you take your chances with your billion friends? If you are a U.S. resident but travel to Europe one week a year, do you request your employer pay you 1/52nd in euros each week or do you take your chances with dollars? The practical reality is that almost all individuals store value in a single monetary asset, not because others do not exist but rather because it is the most liquid asset within their market economy.
Anyone with Venezuelan bolivars or Argentine pesos would opt into the dollar system if they could. And similarly, anyone choosing to speculate in a copy of bitcoin is making the irrational decision to voluntarily opt-in to a less liquid, less secure monetary network. While certain monetary networks are larger and more liquid than bitcoin today (e.g. the dollar, euro, yen), individuals choosing to store a percentage of their wealth in bitcoin are doing so, on average, because of the belief that it is more secure (decentralized → censorship-resistant → fixed supply → store of value). And, because of the expectation that others (e.g. a billion soon-to-be friends) will also opt-in, increasing liquidity and trading partners.
“Anyone choosing to speculate in a copy of bitcoin is making the irrational decision to voluntarily opt-in to a less liquid, less secure monetary network.”
Why Bitcoin Can’t Be Copied
Many individuals creating digital currencies neither accept or admit that what they are creating has to be money to succeed; others that are speculating in these assets fail to understand that monetary systems tend to one medium or naively believe that their currency can out-compete bitcoin. None of them can explain how their digital currency of choice becomes more decentralized, more censorship-resistant or develops more liquidity than bitcoin. To take that further, no other digital currency will likely ever achieve the minimum level of decentralization or censorship-resistance required to have a credibly enforced monetary policy.
Bitcoin is valuable, not because of a particular feature, but instead, because it achieved finite, digital scarcity, through which it derives its store of value property. The credibility of bitcoin’s scarcity (and monetary policy) only exists because it is decentralized and censorship-resistant, which in itself has very little to do with software. In aggregate, this drives incremental adoption and liquidity which reinforces and strengthens the value of the bitcoin network. As part of this process, individuals are, at the same time, opting out of inferior monetary networks. This is fundamentally why the emergent properties in bitcoin are next to impossible to replicate and why bitcoin cannot be copied or out-competed: because bitcoin already exists as an option and its monetary properties become stronger over time (and with greater scale), while also at the direct expense of inferior monetary networks.
One would likely never come to this conclusion without first developing their own understanding of the following: i) that bitcoin is finitely scarce (how/why); ii) that bitcoin is valuable because it is scarce; and iii) that monetary networks tend to one medium. You may come to different conclusions, but this is the appropriate framework to consider when contemplating whether it is possible to copy (or out-compete) bitcoin rather than a framework based on any particular feature set. It’s also important to recognize that any individual’s conclusions, including your own or my own, has very little bearing in the equation. Instead, what matters is what the market consensus believes and what it converges on as the most credible long-term store of value.
The empirical evidence (price mechanism %story% value) demonstrates that the market continues to determine why bitcoin is different, despite a significant amount of noise. Before speculating, try to understand why bitcoin works and why it’s unique. When someone inevitably tells you about a better bitcoin or some differentiating feature, remember that the market, which has come to this same crossroad over the last decade before you, has considered those trade-offs and chosen bitcoin over the field for very rational reasons.
The Minority Rule
Nassim Taleb writes about how a very small intransigent minority can force its preference on the majority, referring to it as the minority rule and explaining why The Most Intolerant Wins. Bitcoin (and monetary systems) are a perfect example of this phenomenon. If a very small minority converges on the belief that bitcoin has superior monetary properties and will not accept your form of digital (or traditional) currency as money, while less convicted market participants accept both bitcoin and other currencies, the intolerant minority wins. This is exactly what is happening in the global competition for digital currency supremacy. A small minority of market participants has determined that only bitcoin is viable, rejecting the monetary properties of all other digital currencies, while the majority is willing to accept bitcoin along with the field. Because of its intransigence, the minority is slowly forcing its preference on the majority. In the world of digital currencies, diversifying by picking the field is the equivalent of letting the crowd (or the intolerant minority) choose what your future money will be, while resigning yourself to only a fraction of what you otherwise would have saved. Evaluate the trade-offs and consider the minority rule before trading in your hard-earned value for a flyer. Money doesn’t grow on trees.
“Bitcoin is a remarkable cryptographic achievement, and the ability to create something that is not duplicable in the digital world has enormous value.” – Eric Schmidt (Former Google CEO).
bitcoin пополнить bitcoin p2p новости bitcoin bitcoin blocks stake bitcoin bitcoin конец Ключевое слово bcc bitcoin wiki ethereum график bitcoin clame bitcoin maining bitcoin secp256k1 bitcoin
bitcoin торговля
bitcoin cranes store bitcoin ethereum cryptocurrency bitcoin gambling
bitmakler ethereum bitcoin favicon
testnet bitcoin
gif bitcoin auction bitcoin
matteo monero escrow bitcoin bitcoin solo ethereum котировки fasterclick bitcoin bitcoin valet
habrahabr bitcoin bitcoin оборот bitcoin опционы команды bitcoin mac bitcoin bitcoin оборудование покер bitcoin сеть bitcoin market bitcoin qiwi bitcoin bitcoin шахта bitcoin system обмен monero программа tether bitcoin algorithm store bitcoin карты bitcoin monero minergate antminer ethereum token ethereum
bitcoin prune bitcoin air wmx bitcoin ethereum node bitcoin основы A block must specify a parent, and it must specify 0 or more unclesbitcoin doge bitcoin click компьютер bitcoin bitcoin earning bitcoin shop bitcoin акции mining cryptocurrency bitcoin минфин ethereum addresses фото bitcoin bitcoin frog
flypool ethereum bitcoin roulette blender bitcoin
copay bitcoin bitcoin автосерфинг
ethereum install cryptocurrency bitcoin monero spelunker ethereum install bitcoin пул
bitcoin xt
покупка ethereum создать bitcoin bitcoin автокран bitcoin foto field bitcoin пожертвование bitcoin By creating a world in which there is a fixed money supply such that no more or no less can be saved in aggregate, the incentive and propensity to save increases measurably on the individual level. It is a paradox; if more money cannot be saved in aggregate, more people will save on an individual basis. On one hand, it may appear to be a simple statement that individuals value scarcity. But in reality, it is more so an explanation that an incentive to save creates savers, even if more money can’t be saved in aggregate. And in order for someone to save, someone else must spend existing savings. After all, all consumption and investment comes from savings; the incentive to save creates savers, and the existence of more savers in turn creates more people with the means to consume and invest. At an individual level, if someone expects a monetary unit to increase in purchasing power, he or she might reasonably defer either consumption or investment to the future (the key word being ‘defer’). That is the incentive to save creating savers. It doesn’t eliminate consumption or investment; it merely ensures that the decision is evaluated with greater scrutiny when future purchasing power is expected to increase, not decrease. Imagine every single person simultaneously operating with that incentive mechanism, compared to the opposite which exists today.bubble bitcoin
видеокарты bitcoin golden bitcoin bitcoin фильм No one needs to know or trust anyone in particular in order for the system to operate correctly. Assuming everything is working as intended, the cryptographic protocols ensure that each block of transactions is bolted onto the last in a long, transparent, and immutable chain. total cryptocurrency код bitcoin теханализ bitcoin bitcoin formula зарегистрировать bitcoin бонусы bitcoin hashrate bitcoin ann ethereum zcash bitcoin bitcoin demo flash bitcoin bitcoin cards collector bitcoin bitcoin p2p теханализ bitcoin ethereum сбербанк bitcoin краны проверка bitcoin monero cpu monero dwarfpool bitcoin stealer bitcoin euro bitcoin коллектор
kran bitcoin
bitcoin разделился bitcoin stealer
monero ico bitcoin get bitcoin advcash bitcoin ваучер раздача bitcoin перевод ethereum 8 bitcoin account bitcoin hack bitcoin bitcoin multisig bitcoin up tether майнинг bank bitcoin ethereum forks bitcoin airbit bitcoin кликер bitcoin dat bitcointalk ethereum bitcoin sha256 bitcoin mining production cryptocurrency статистика ethereum ethereum com программа bitcoin
bitcoin capitalization app bitcoin ethereum pools
bitcoin вложить bitcoin ios заработка bitcoin ethereum supernova
bitcoin cap краны ethereum 50 bitcoin удвоитель bitcoin bitcoin cms
пулы bitcoin
skrill bitcoin bitcoin cz bitcoin биржи nicehash bitcoin майнеры monero bitcoin 10 bitcoin pattern flappy bitcoin short bitcoin hacking bitcoin bitcoin webmoney bitcoin bat bitcoin бесплатный bitcoin nodes calculator ethereum rigname ethereum bitcoin utopia bitcoin теория testnet bitcoin торги bitcoin ethereum контракты bitcoin сети стоимость ethereum arbitrage bitcoin bitcoin сатоши bitcoin demo bitcoin carding bitcoin capitalization bitcoin ecdsa кран ethereum bitcoin poloniex
PeepEth: PeepEth is a decentralized Twitter alternative. Twitter has the ability to delete accounts and tweets if the company finds them unfavorable. PeepEth is different: although moderators keep the main feed to free of spam and inappropriate posts, 'peeps' posted to PeepEth cannot be deleted. And when the Gardner brothers have a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.*Bitcoin, cryptocurrency, blockchain... So what does it all mean? asics bitcoin bitcoin конвертер
apple bitcoin ethereum телеграмм брокеры bitcoin bitcoin github ферма ethereum bitcoin терминалы bitcoin пополнить bitcoin machine x bitcoin daemon monero
monero обмен bitcoin converter value bitcoin keys bitcoin monero кран
monero proxy cryptocurrency charts ethereum raiden fork ethereum cryptocurrency charts bitcoin магазин ethereum mine xmr monero bitcoin обмена bitcoin talk bitcoin primedice
byzantium ethereum bitcoin transaction Size:bitcoin автосборщик accept bitcoin ethereum контракты bitcoin future ethereum контракты monero пул
bitcoin pools bitcoin change кошельки bitcoin
bitcoin вложения криптовалюту bitcoin ethereum core monero coin bitcoin direct bus bitcoin tether provisioning ethereum логотип tails bitcoin
bitcoin evolution акции bitcoin ферма bitcoin service bitcoin poloniex ethereum captcha bitcoin blog bitcoin Defining digital trustBecause bitcoin mining is best achieved through pooling (joining a group of thousands of other miners), the organizers of each pool choose how to divide bitcoins that are discovered. Bitcoin mining pool organizers can dishonestly take more bitcoin mining shares for themselves.mikrotik bitcoin bitcoin программирование topfan bitcoin location bitcoin bitcoin 4096 майнинга bitcoin bitcoin china bitcoin cnbc dogecoin bitcoin blitz bitcoin p2pool ethereum bitcoin neteller bitcoin talk bitcoin bestchange chaindata ethereum
порт bitcoin bitcoin market bitcoin machines bitcoin avalon ethereum info контракты ethereum
bitcoin pay ethereum падение
bitcoin история bitcoin income bitcoin cache cranes bitcoin bitcoin foto
ethereum developer настройка monero bitcoin бесплатно bitcoin суть avto bitcoin bubble bitcoin iphone tether bitcoin автосборщик bitcoin часы boom bitcoin депозит bitcoin loan bitcoin config bitcoin mainer bitcoin
платформа bitcoin blender bitcoin
андроид bitcoin cms bitcoin bitcoin count qiwi bitcoin bitcoin fire Nonce—this field contains a random value (the nonce value) whose sole purpose is to act as a variate for the hash valuebitcoin книга ethereum chart bitcoin динамика отдам bitcoin field bitcoin bitcoin суть mining bitcoin bitcoin download buy ethereum
ethereum ротаторы bitfenix bitcoin bitcoin 10 get bitcoin
bitcoin автоматически monero poloniex статистика ethereum pool bitcoin birds bitcoin ставки bitcoin bitcoin cny faucet bitcoin bitcoin значок game bitcoin coingecko ethereum мониторинг bitcoin
bitcoin сбор bitcoin goldman bitcoin code bitcoin fire bitcoin ocean bitcoin x2
1070 ethereum pool bitcoin prune bitcoin кликер bitcoin майнить bitcoin avatrade bitcoin bitcoin reddit bitcoin nvidia брокеры bitcoin wild bitcoin
bestchange bitcoin raspberry bitcoin reddit ethereum
основатель ethereum importprivkey bitcoin токен ethereum bitcoin registration bitcoin cudaminer surf bitcoin криптовалюту monero ethereum отзывы bitcointalk monero bitcoin media ethereum rig bitcoin аккаунт видеокарта bitcoin ethereum ios bitcoin вектор ethereum programming bitcoin бонусы bitcoin gift bitcoin деньги delphi bitcoin bitcoin neteller кости bitcoin bitcoin кости cryptonator ethereum bitcoin ru TWITTERbitcoin переводчик Bitcoin mining a block is difficult because the SHA-256 hash of a block's header must be lower than or equal to the target in order for the block to be accepted by the network.monero 1060 fx bitcoin live bitcoin doge bitcoin бесплатный bitcoin основатель ethereum ethereum miner bitcoin today bitcoin зарегистрироваться
проекта ethereum bazar bitcoin bitcoin xyz bitcoin space bitcoin ферма bitcoin рубль ethereum charts
testnet bitcoin bitcoin information buy tether
зарегистрироваться bitcoin сайты bitcoin unconfirmed bitcoin bitcoin symbol bitcoin donate халява bitcoin бесплатный bitcoin pow bitcoin скрипт bitcoin
wirex bitcoin bitcoin com
dorks bitcoin bitcoin fpga cryptonote monero tether 4pda ethereum solidity
mercado bitcoin bitcoin email покер bitcoin bitcoin fpga bitcoin cz ethereum supernova bitcoin froggy bitcoin мавроди bitcoin перевод bitcoin развод tether майнинг сайты bitcoin login bitcoin bitcoin center
ethereum прогнозы Not debt-basedпроект bitcoin сервера bitcoin coinbase ethereum обменник bitcoin minersThese are the concepts behind money that people need to understand. Gold’s value is due to its specific attributes, and the dollar’s value is due to legal force.теханализ bitcoin котировки ethereum app bitcoin bitcoin ann конференция bitcoin datadir bitcoin bitcoin что tether 4pda monero новости курс ethereum bitcoin genesis bitcoin пирамиды bitcoin курс mempool bitcoin cryptocurrency arbitrage monero simplewallet ethereum валюта card bitcoin json bitcoin bitcoin center ann monero takara bitcoin monero proxy вход bitcoin ethereum complexity bitcoin xt bitcoin elena bitcoin paw mine monero 10000 bitcoin дешевеет bitcoin ethereum nicehash bitcoin protocol ethereum coingecko кошельки ethereum bitcoin anonymous bitcoin asics
проекта ethereum To understand the impact of Bitcoin, we return to Coase, and his theory that firms exist to reduce the transaction costs of specialists who collaborate in business. If peer to peer currency systems can lower financial transaction costs enough, they may eliminate the benefit of large firms entirely, replacing them with loosely-aggregated groups of SMBs sharing commonly-maintained infrastructure.зарегистрироваться bitcoin usa bitcoin ethereum акции tether usb
bitcoin ios bitcoin earning market bitcoin solo bitcoin bitcoin вектор платформы ethereum node bitcoin биржа monero bitcoin russia криптовалют ethereum equihash bitcoin bitcoin hype wallet cryptocurrency
bitcoin форум bitcoin презентация кошелек ethereum криптовалюта tether apk tether bitcoin bbc local ethereum all cryptocurrency bitcoin novosti cms bitcoin bitcoin котировки
bitcoin комментарии сложность bitcoin bitcoin usd fx bitcoin
bitcoin markets bitcoin generator bitcoin casino bcc bitcoin bitcoin бизнес tether android accept bitcoin ethereum телеграмм oil bitcoin bitcoin antminer ethereum asics мастернода ethereum bitcoin media bitcoin biz
tether tools bitcoin frog bitcoin sec analysis bitcoin
bitcoin транзакции ethereum api bitcoin wiki bitcoin p2pool bitcoin заработка bitcoin видеокарты новости bitcoin bitcoin ммвб bitcoin таблица pos ethereum ethereum telegram биржа monero up bitcoin bitcoin conveyor
ethereum org bip bitcoin electrum bitcoin casinos bitcoin rbc bitcoin ethereum erc20 payable ethereum bitcoin цены bitcoin crane биржи monero
bitcoin обсуждение
daemon monero etherium bitcoin bitcoin hd tether 4pda bitcoin китай
monero wallet pool bitcoin майнинга bitcoin matrix bitcoin future bitcoin ethereum упал pow bitcoin bitcoin me bitcoin skrill бесплатные bitcoin google bitcoin
decred cryptocurrency обменять ethereum bitcoin block bitcoin миллионер bitcoin шахта china bitcoin mastering bitcoin bitcoin кэш cranes bitcoin сбербанк ethereum monero прогноз tether tools x2 bitcoin monero hardware 2. Task Assignment Mechanismnetwork bitcoin bitcoin paw bitcoin nodes bitcoin security bitcoin trust
bitcoin payoneer Note: dApps are like regular apps (like Facebook, Google or Twitter) but they run on a blockchain, not a central server. You can find out more about dApps in our 'What is a dApp' guide.ethereum pow перспективы ethereum capitalization cryptocurrency bitcoin map история ethereum js bitcoin monero minergate bitcoin forum таблица bitcoin live bitcoin прогноз ethereum tether скачать bitcoin мерчант charts bitcoin
ethereum stratum bitcoin hunter bitcoin инвестиции bitcoin compare форк bitcoin
bitcoin vector cryptocurrency nem vk bitcoin
converter bitcoin шахты bitcoin андроид bitcoin kong bitcoin purse bitcoin iso bitcoin bitcoin gambling bitcoin fasttech icons bitcoin monero client monero bitcointalk казино bitcoin доходность ethereum start bitcoin byzantium ethereum арбитраж bitcoin пулы monero ethereum php
ethereum miners bittorrent bitcoin tracker bitcoin bitcoin wmx bitcoin игры average bitcoin блокчейна ethereum ethereum casper bye bitcoin ethereum проблемы usd bitcoin bitcoin loan bitcoin koshelek
secp256k1 ethereum conference bitcoin gadget bitcoin
ubuntu bitcoin korbit bitcoin bitcoin demo bitcoin обменники forum bitcoin future bitcoin capitalization bitcoin
bitcoin 1000 bitcoin avalon instaforex bitcoin ethereum асик bitcoin xapo bitcoin background
bitcoin рбк ethereum coin bitcoin nasdaq bitcoin status bitcoin hesaplama ethereum org hub bitcoin bitcoin coinmarketcap ethereum transactions bitcoin lurkmore купить tether difficulty ethereum bitcoin word bitcoin зарегистрироваться rx580 monero ethereum продать bitcoin развод bitcoin мошенники bitcoin etf